Should You Practice Yoga Or Pilates For Posture? (Answered!)
If you want to attain a good posture, yoga and Pilates can help you. Both have numerous health benefits, which include developing flexibility, strength, and endurance.
If you want to achieve a good posture through a mental restorative process, go for yoga. But if you prefer intense exercises with faster results, Pilates is best for your journey to attain good posture.
Pilates is a system of functional exercises developed by Joseph Pilates. The exercises increase flexibility, strengthens muscles, and helps with better posture. It is suitable for children and adults and all levels of ability and fitness.
Yoga focuses on body awareness and allows you to notice bad postures such as slouching quickly. It helps to improve flexibility and balance and promotes proper body alignment. Yoga is a good choice if you want to achieve mental growth while going through the physical process.
Pilates is a physical exercise performed on a mat or special equipment such as Wunda Chair and reformer that provides support or resistance.
This article will highlight the significant differences and similarities in both systems and why you can opt for one or the other.
How do yoga and Pilates approaches differ to improve posture?
Both yoga and Pilates improve your posture. But yoga focuses on body, mind, and spirit, while Pilates focuses on the body and mind. In yoga, you hold the poses longer and repetitively, while with Pilates, you do shorter and less repetitive poses. Pilates also employs exercise machines, while yoga relies on the body for resistance.
If you’re wondering which approach to choose between Yoga and Pilates for posture, below are some of their key differences.
Yoga focuses on body, mind, and spirit, while Pilates focuses on body and mind.
One of the notable differences between yoga and Pilates approach to improving posture is the element of spirituality.
Yoga’s goal is to achieve a balance between body, mind, and spirit. It leverages meditation and breathing techniques and aims at directing your focus inward to help improve body postures. Conversely, Pilates is an exercise routine that focuses on the body and mind to improve fitness and posture.
The mind-body approach of Pilates makes you more aware of your body and allows you to focus on form and alignment.
For example, Pilate’s reverse plank bridge exercise straightens the lower back and corrects the rounded shoulder.
The chest opens up when doing the reverse plank bridge, allowing the shoulders and spine to align.
This targets major muscle groups such as rhomboids, front deltoids, and hip flexors responsible for good postures.
Long and repetitive yoga poses vs. short and less repetitive Pilates movements
Both yoga and Pilates involves moves, but they’re different in style and time spent holding them,
For yoga, poses are usually held for a more extended period. It allows you to fall deep into each pose. You also have to repeat sequences in a single session. Shorter movements and less repetition characterize Pilates.
Unlike yoga, you do not have to repeat moves or spend a long time on Pilates. Instead, you progress from one activity to the other in short bursts.
Yoga relies on the body’s resistance, while Pilates employs exercise machines
Pilates classes use fitness machines to challenge the body, while yoga uses guided meditation and relaxation techniques.
Yoga relies on the body to serve as resistance. Apart from a mat, it uses minor equipment such as blocks, straps, or a blanket to aid poses.
Whereas, in the case of Pilates, exercise machines such as spine corrector, small barrel, Cadillac, and the reformer are involved. These machines are used to assist the body in improving strength and restoring body alignment.
Machines help the body in shaky situations and help build stability in the body’s core, thereby enhancing body posture.
Similarities between Yoga and Pilates approach for posture improvement
As there are differences, there are also similarities in both systems.
Both Pilates and yoga build your core strength, improve posture awareness and flexibility, and strengthen the upper body and trunk.
Here are some of the areas of convergence between yoga and Pilates.
Both build core strength
Yoga emphasizes the importance of strengthening the core muscles. The muscle groups controlling the lumbar spine are crucial to achieving better posture.
Similarly, Pilates has various exercises focused on developing core strength. You would train your body to contract and release muscles, thereby increasing overall muscle strength.
Both enhance posture awareness
Yoga promotes body awareness which results in posture awareness. Pilates also improves posture awareness through active awareness of the muscles.
Through the series of yoga poses, you will focus on the physical aspects of the process, such as movement and position, which improve body awareness.
By being aware of your body, you’ll maximize body function, which allows you to be conscious of your posture. This helps you improve your posture.
The same case goes for Pilates. Apart from its emphasis on strengthening the core muscles, there’s a Pilates aspect called active awareness of the muscles.
Through understanding the importance of good muscles and body alignment, you’ll become more aware of your posture, which leads to better posture.
Both increase flexibility
A huge part of Yoga poses and Pilates stretches is attaining greater flexibility.
There are many poses in yoga that help you strengthen your postural muscles and reduce muscle stiffness.
For example, the Cow Face Pose (Gomukhasana) enhances flexibility by stretching your biceps, pectorals, trapezius, and serratus anterior. This is an excellent solution to the slouching you do while sitting.
By engaging in it frequently, you can improve your posture.
Pilates has stretches that can help you develop and improve flexibility. As you stretch the muscles, it enables you to maintain physical integrity and alignment.
Let’s take the Saw exercise, for instance. It helps develop scapular and pelvic stability while increasing flexibility in the hips, spine, and shoulder regions.
This also provides a good stretch for the hamstrings. All around, Pilates emphasizes flexibility to maintain good postural balance.
Both train your upper body and trunk
Both yoga and Pilates train your upper body and trunk, which allows you to control your posture.
With Yoga, you can boost postural muscles and strengthen the upper body and trunk. It also helps you build muscular endurance, which aids good posture.
While many yoga poses focus on building lower body strength, several poses focus on the upper body. An example is a handstand.
Many people think the handstand is for advanced yoga practitioners. It is not true. It is an essential yoga pose that helps the upper body at any level.
The handstand will make your upper body stronger, increase your balance, and build core strength. All of these are needed to achieve good posture.
For Pilates, several exercises help you gain flexibility in your shoulders, arms, and back, which can enhance your upper body and trunk. For example, the Pilates push-up.
The Pilates push-up is a total body exercise that helps you strengthen your arms and shoulders.
It is an excellent exercise to stabilize your upper body and build strong muscles, which improves your posture.
Should you do Yoga or Pilates to improve posture?
Yoga and Pilates are ideal for posture improvement. They both help you gain flexibility, strengthen muscles, and overall body wellness.
Depending on your goals, either can be perfect for you.
If your goal to achieve a good posture is to go through a mental restorative process, go for yoga. But if you prefer intense workouts, Pilates is best for you in your journey to attain good posture.
Also, because yoga and Pilates have fundamental differences in their approach, the experience can vary.
Yoga classes can help you improve postural awareness and also promote proper alignment. In addition, you can sign up for Tai Chi classes to get guided sessions on improving posture.
Pilates is also essential to maintaining good posture because it trains you to develop core strength, increase range of motion and achieve proper body alignment.
Conclusion
Yoga and Pilates are both excellent if you’re looking to develop flexibility, balance, strength, and ultimately, good posture.
Yoga and Pilates emphasize the link between mental and physical.
While yoga focuses on meditation and relaxation, Pilates is performed without static poses and is done through the flow of movements on mats and equipment like the reformer, Wunda Chair, and Cadillac.
If your goal is to achieve a good posture and to go through a mental restorative journey in the process, go for yoga. But if you prefer intense workouts that leave out the introspective side, Pilates is ideal for you to attain a good posture.
Whichever one you go for will be based on your needs, physical fitness, and what you’re trying to achieve.
You may also like 👉 Yoga Versus Pilates For Back Pain